A despairing police officer told today (Wed) how he tried in vain to coax a suicidal man off a 120ft bridge.
Mwitumwa Ngenda, a 30-year-old father-of-two, was in a distressed state on the morning of 28 August last year after Greater Manchester Police (GMP) released a picture of a man they wished to question regarding an alleged rape offence.
The story was published in the Manchester Evening News, (MEN), and drew a large response. It turned out Mr Ngenda was the man identified and he immediately handed himself in for questioning while making it clear that he vehemently denied the offence.
His parents, Dr Love Mwitumwa Ngenda and his wife Gladys, along with his ex-wife Beth Morgan, listened to five hours of evidence at Bradford Coroner’s Court about how their son fell to his death from Rainbow Bridge which spans the M62 at Scammonden.
Although he was a bubbly and much-liked bank worker at RBS in Manchester he had a history of depression and suffered anxiety attacks. On the morning of his death he had borrowed his sister’s Peugeot car and driven to the bridge.
Coroner Martin Fleming heard how PC Michael Caulfield desperately tried to talk him down after being alerted to fears about a man on the bridge.
In written evidence read to the court he told how he did everything possible to avoid him leaping and how he had recorded their conversation on his body camera.
The officer asked Mr Ngenda to tell his story and he spoke about the rape allegation which was made on July 8. The officer recalled: “Someone had made an allegation and it would be in the papers. I said I would spend all day there if required. He said he didn’t want to be arrested and in handcuffs.
“He told me to step back. At one time I managed to get him to smile. He didn’t come back over the barrier and at 7.40am he let go and fell from my sight onto the carriageway.
“I was shocked at what had happened and I composed myself as best I could.”
Where to get help if you're struggling
You don't have to suffer in silence if you're struggling with your mental health. Here are some groups you can contact when you need help.
Samaritans: Phone 116 123, 24 hours a day, or email firstname.lastname@example.org, in confidence
Childline: Phone 0800 1111. Calls are free and won't show up on your bill
PAPYRUS: A voluntary organisation supporting suicidal teens and young adults. Phone 0800 068 4141
Depression Alliance: A charity for people with depression. No helpline but offers useful resources and links to other information
Students Against Depression: A website for students who are depressed, have low mood, or are suicidal. Click here to visit
Bullying UK: A website for both children and adults affected by bullying. Click here
Campaign Against Living Miserably (CALM): For young men who are feeling unhappy. Has a website and a helpline: 0800 58 58 58
Later Mr Ngenda’s parents watched their son’s final, harrowing conversation with the officer as recorded on his body camera.
A transcript of the remarks was then read to the court which were described by Mr Fleming as “undeniably the most distressing transcript I have had to listen to. A desperately sad case.”
PC Caulfield did a brilliant job trying to engage with Mr Ngenda telling him his name and trying to bond with him saying they both had ex-wives. He said: “You have got me for as long as it takes. You will have a mate for life. If you want a cuddle we will have a ‘man cuddle’.”
When Mr Ngenda, who lived at his parents’ address in Idle, Bradford, told him not to worry, he replied: “I do, it’s my job.
“I might be a daft, gobby, rugby player but I want you to come back in the same way you arrived. You have got a choice. We can go somewhere and talk.”
However, despite his efforts Mr Ngenda fell to his death.
A pathologist said he died from multiple injuries and death would have been instantaneous.
In a statement read to the court Dr Ngenda said that on August 24 he received a phone call at 8pm from his son saying he was at a police station in Manchester. He, (Mr Ngenda), spent the night there.
“At 11am on August 25 I received a phone call saying he had been taken into Manchester Hospital and he was waiting to be collected. I drove him home.”
Later on August 26 he said his son seemed fine and in the morning he was lying outstretched on a sofa.
Dr Ngenda said: “There was an allegation from a lady about a party he had been to. He had had a lot to drink at the party. He is not normally very talkative but we even had a beer together in the evening. Next day he seemed fine. We left him on the sofa.”
However, on the 28th his room was checked and he was not there and his sister’s red Peugeot was missing. He said his wife was panicking and the police told them he was deceased.
He added: “Neither myself or my wife can believe what has happened. We are very shocked and upset.”
The court heard an internal investigation by Det Sgt Deborah Wood of GMP was carried out to see how the Force had conducted itself regarding the rape allegation and the release of the press appeal. She found there was nothing amiss.
She said that after it was published by the MEN Mr Ngenda immediately handed himself in to police for questioning. He had been represented by a solicitor and had been seen by the custody officer before being discharged and bailed until September 11.
Mr Fleming said: “He was properly risk-assessed and driven back to his home address. There was an incident the next day and he was taken in by police. He seemed a little bit under the weather.”
He said there had been a “worrying exchange of text messages” between Mr Ngenda and two friends just before his death which made clear “his intention to end his life. It’s clear that the criminal allegation against him was weighing very heavily on his mind.”
He said that in addition the breakdown of his marriage and separation from his children had not helped. He added: “It’s clear that these developments were the catalyst to put him in a very dark place indeed.
He concluded the text messages and notes he left behind were indicative of his intention “that he intended to take his own life.”